Comments from Our Readers: While Sherwin Williams Denied Extended Hours, Residents Should Still Demand Results from Dust Testing

At the City Hall meeting (Tues Sept 6), I raised the issue of the dust with high lead content during the public comment period. Surprisingly enough, no local residents came to raise this issue. A rep from the artists’ co-op was the only other public commenter, and she said that most of the people who attended the artists’ co-op supported the extended work hours, with only a “couple of” people strongly opposed, and she ignored the “toxic dust” issue altogether.

Surprisingly enough, Larry Mencin did not take the podium to address the lead in dust/testing issue I had publicly called to the Council’s attention, and initially it looked like the City Council itself was going to brush over it.

However, after some extended discussion about the noise and impact on quality of life that would result based on the proposed after hours work, both Ruth and Jennifer DID ask questions about dust testing. At that time Larry Mencin did step up to the podium and confirmed that they just ran some tests and hope to have results back soon. I suspect he was advised not to even mention the positive (they DID run tests, according to him) unless there was no choice but to do so (is that transparency?).

I urge residents who are sincerely concerned about this issue to press Larry at the resident meetings or via Mara Feeney, and to do it promptly. While you no longer have the leverage of opposing the extended work hours, I think anybody wondering about what they are breathing over there should ask to see the tests.

When it came to voting on the extended hours, Ruth proposed modifying the developer’s proposal to eliminate any Sunday work altogether, and to eliminate the use of dump trucks both at night and on Saturday. She proposed to allow rail car dirt removal only, since the rail cars pick up at the north end where there haven’t been any complaints. I thought Ruth’s compromise proposal was a thoughtful balancing which would allow the project to get done more quickly (before the possibility of rains completely blow the schedule for completion) while giving residents at least one day of rest and keeping the noisiest part of the work, the dump trucks, off the streets. I was happy to see her oppose Nora, who was pretty much completely pro-developer, and stand up for the residents EVEN WHEN RESIDENTS DIDN’T SHOW UP.

Usually Nora is very savvy about informally asking the other council members how they expect to vote, but she didn’t this time, apparently confident that she would quash Ruth’s compromise position and get approval for the developer’s full proposal (although the developer agreed to take Sunday work off both alternatives).

And then in a stunning reversal of fortune, Ruth’s amended extended hours motion failed to get enough votes, but then Nora’s un-amended proposal also went down in flames.

Sherwin Williams went home very unhappy campers.

Michael Webber is a candidate for Emeryville City Council

(To comment on this story, or to read the comments of others, click the headline to go to the story page, then scroll to the bottom).

Posted in Business/Economy, City Hall, Uncategorized | 1 Comment

Why Buy Local?

Bucci's restaurant owners Paul Camardo, Amelia Bucci, and Leslie Julian at their Hollis Street restaurant in Emeryville, which opened (at another location in town) 24 years ago. Stories about Bucci's and other local businesses in town coming soon in The Secret News.

Why should Emeryville support locally-owned businesses?

Shopping is a political act.  Where we choose to plunk down our dollars has implications far beyond our own household budgets.  Supporting local business helps the local economy and makes our communities stronger.

Locally-owned — what does it mean?

Shopping locally does not mean driving into the parking lot of your nearby big-box mall and going from box to box to do your shopping.  Shopping ‘local’ means sticking to the stores that have their roots in your own community…it may be a mom-‘n-pop, one-of-a-kind place of business, or a small local chain that started out small.  In any case, we are talking about stores that have local ownership, local management, and are closely attuned to the particular needs of their customers.

Keep your money in your community

According to a study done in 2003 in Austin, Texas by the American Independence Business Alliance, when you spend $100 at a nationwide chain store, only $13 stays in the local economy.  But spend that same $100 at a locally owned store and $45 stays to support the local economy.  Think about it.  It goes beyond the profits, which, of course go to “the headquarters in New York City.” For one thing, independent stores employ their managers and buyers locally, while a chain may have only a low-level manager on site.  The fact of more higher-paying jobs per location brings the local stores’ average wages up.  And there’s more.

Support an expanding local network

Independent stores source more of their products locally, giving area artisans, farmers and producers more of edge and a chance to market their goods.  Locally-owned businesses purchase their supplies and services from local vendors as well, thus spreading the wealth around the community.  For example, if a local store wants to expand, it will hire a local contractor who, in turn, employs local workers.  Bankers, accountants, lawyers, and window-washers all benefit.

Reduce environmental impact

Purchases from independent stores require less transportation from producer to point-of-sale.  Chain stores ship goods to regional warehouses and then turn around and reship to the final destination store, while local stores can cut out pieces of that transportation web.  You, the shopper, travel less distance to purchase goods in your own neighborhood, and may be able to bike or walk.

Relish better customer service

Research shows that small business owners focus on high quality customer service to maintain their edge against the chains.  Because they are involved in the development and running of their business, they are more likely to be knowledgeable about their field and about the products they sell. The owner of an excellent lighting store in Berkeley told me of the time he spent a half hour explaining the pros and cons of various lighting systems to a couple, only to have the wife say to her husband, “Okay, let’s go buy it at Home Depot.

Make a small change; make a big difference

Local First of Grand Rapids, MI did a study in September of 2008 examining the impact of local business on the western Michigan economy.  Their study revealed that a modest change in consumer behavior—merely a 10% shift in buying from chain-stores to independent businesses—would result in 1,600 new jobs, $53 million in wages, and a $137 million economic boon to the area in many sectors, not only retail.  Elissa Sangalli Hillary, the executive director, said, “So often, individuals feel overwhelmed and unable to make a difference.  The study shows that by choosing to support locally owned business, individuals can help to create and retain jobs in [their] community.”

Local retailers are your friends and neighbors – support them and they will support you and make your neighborhoods more livable. “More independents means more choice, more diversity and a truly unique community,” according to IndieBound, a national movement to support local, independent businesses. It’s worth it to give financial as well as intangible support to local businesses.  It’s worth it to spend tax dollars to attract and maintain them.  We all will reap the benefits.

(Photo by Scott Donahue)

(To comment on this story and/or to read the comments of others, click the headline to go to the story page, then scroll to the bottom).

Posted in Arts/Culture, Business/Economy | 3 Comments

City Council Meeting Sept. 6: Sherwin Williams’ Request for Extended Work Hours

The Emeryville City Council will consider Sherwin Williams’ request to extend its work hours at the Horton and 45th streets clean-up site to include

A 12-foot-high wall from just north of 45th Street to the Novartis parking lot, contains the clean-up operation, shielding it from public view. Sherwin Williams had solicited the community for Haiku celebrating their paint colors to adorn the wall, but apparently received few submissions. The few they did get are obscured by heavy scaffolding and "No Trespassing" signs.

Saturdays and evenings until 9 pm. Current hours are 7 am to 6 pm on weekdays. The clean up has been ongoing for 45 days and is expected to continue for at least another three months.

Despite repeated requests from neighborhood residents, Sherwin Williams, the state Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC), and Bay Area Air Quality Management (BAAQM) have so far refused to conduct testing of dust being generated by the clean-up. Soil at the site contains arsenic, lead, and benzene, among other toxins. Sherwin Williams now says it is working with DTSC to configure a dust sampling plan, but so far no sampling has been done. Several residents first complained of the dust three weeks ago, including a call to the BAAQM hotline.

Mara Feeney, a public relations person hired by Sherwin William to address community concerns, said that they have problems with testing of the dust because “there is no ‘baseline’ data to use for scientific comparison.” Sherwin Williams has the same resources as any other multi-billion dollar corporation, with the very best technology at its disposal. The question that has arisen is why didn’t it establish, and record, a “baseline” before it began its remediation work?

Emeryville residents with concerns about the Sherwin Williams remediation project are strongly encouraged to attend the Tuesday, Sept. 6 meeting. The meeting will be held at 7 pm, City Council chambers, City Hall.

See previous Secret News post for more information.

(To comment on this story, or to read the comments of others, please click on the headline to go to the story page, then scroll to the bottom.)

Posted in Business/Economy, City Hall | Leave a comment

Pixar’s Wall-E @ Studio One, Oakland

At Dusk, Sept. 23

Studio One is very near E’ville–365 45th Street in Oakland!  Come see a screening of Pixar’s Wall-E.  All films screened in the Summer Movie series begin @ dusk.  Be sure to dress warm and bring a blanket.

Posted in Events | Leave a comment

The Fantastic Mr. Fox @ Studio One, Oakland

At dusk, Sept. 9th, Movies in the Courtyard @ Studio One in Oakland
Studio One is very near E’ville–365 45th Street in Oakland!  Come see a screening of The Fantastic Mr. Fox.  On Sept. 23rd, Studio One will screen Pixar’s Wall-E.  All films screened in the Summer Movie series begin @ dusk.  Be sure to dress warm and bring a blanket.
Posted in Events | Leave a comment

Is It Safe?

Sherwin Williams asks for extended work hours (evenings, Saturdays), while refusing repeated requests for testing

Bulldozers generating dust during clean-up of Sherwin Williams property

Sherwin Williams has spent the past 45 days cleaning up the mess it made during its heyday dacades ago, when it was busy “covering the world.” And it’s quite a mess. More than 8 acres of land at the corner of Sherwin and Horton streets in Emeryville is contaminated with arsenic, lead, and solvents like benzene.

While the clean-up –- reportedly just one-third of the way done –- is good news, the bad news is the clean-up is generating dust – a dust that residents say is sticking to their cars, blowing into their open apartment windows, and leaving a layer of grit on their morning newspapers.

“It’s a change I’ve noticed since the clean up started,” said nearby resident Archana Horsting, referring to the dust on her newspaper. “I feel like I need to wash my hands because I don’t know what it is.”

A list of some of the toxins contained in the soil, posted in the window of the Sherwin Williams office facing Sherwin Street

Horsting, a long-time resident of the Emeryville Artists’ Cooperative (EAC) and Executive Director of the Kala Art Institute in Berkeley, spoke at a recent meeting between EAC residents, and representatives of Sherwin-Williams (S-W) and the state Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC), which is charged with monitoring clean-up safety. Sherwin Williams requested the meeting to notify residents it will be asking the City Council for a permit to extend clean-up hours to include Saturdays, and weekday nights until  9 pm. As it is, work starts at 7 a.m. and ends at 6 pm. S-W says it’s behind schedule and wants to finish before the November rains, which will make the operation more difficult, and more expensive.

Sherwin Williams will make its request at the City Council’s Sept. 6 meeting.

Initially blaming other possible sources, like street cleaning, S-W representatives at the meeting finally conceded that the site might be the source of the dust, but it was from a non-toxic, dirt-like material added to the toxic sludge so they can load and transport it more easily. But many EAC residents attending the meeting asked how Sherwin Williams can be sure if it won’t test.

“Can you test it (the dust), just to put our minds at ease?,” asked EAC Board Member Robin Bernstein.

When pressed, Mara Feeney, a public relations person hired by Sherwin Williams to deal with community concerns, finally agreed to query the company further about the possibility. However, several days later, she said, “They (S-W) have issues with it, since the dust testing that was done years ago was inconclusive and there is no ‘baseline’ data to use for scientific comparison.”

With regard to other EAC residents’ concerns over the extended work hours, like noise, she said engineers will “try their best” to work around EAC members’ schedules.

A 12-foot-high wall, from just north of 45th Street to the Novartis parking lot, contains the clean-up operation, shielding it from public view. Sherwin Williams had solicited the community for Haiku celebrating their paint colors to adorn the wall, but apparently received few submissions. The ones they did get are obscured by scaffolding and "No Trespassing" signs.

Meanwhile, S-W and DTSC representatives at the meeting said there are plenty of safeguards in place, including mist machines designed to keep down the dust, and air monitors around the perimeter of the site to measure it’s toxicity. The private company (subcontracted by Sherwin Williams) to ensure the safety of the clean-up was apparently doing some sampling, but stopped after the first few samples were deemed to be within required limits.

Previous requests for testing had been made (by this reporter, who lives at the EAC) both to the DTSC (whose expenses are paid by Sherwin Williams), and Bay Area Air Quality Management (BAAQM). Both have refused, explaining that it appears Sherwin Williams is doing what it should, including taking air monitor readings around the site perimeter, so testing is unnecessary. BAAQM said that, under the circumstances, it “could not justify the expense.”

(To comment on this story, or to read the comments of others, please click on the story headline to go to the story page, then scroll to the bottom).

Posted in Business/Economy, City Hall | 16 Comments

Emeryville City Council Race: Here’s Who’s Running

It’s official. Here are the candidates running for three City Council seats in November. Election Day is Nov. 8. Don’t forget to vote! More information on each candidate will be coming soon in The Secret News.

 

 

 

 

(From left: Jacqueline Asher, incumbents Nora Davis, Ken Bukowski, and Ruth Atkin, and Michael Webber).

(Click on the photos, or the names below, to go to more information about each candidate. In the case of the incumbents, the information provided reflects each of the candidates’ “political philosophy” touted in their last election campaign(s), in 2007. Did their actions over the past four years reflect those philosophies?)

New candidates

Jacqueline Asher

Mike Webber

Incumbents

Ken Bukowski

Nora Davis

Ruth Atkin

(To comment on this story, or to see the comments of others, click on the headline to go to the story page, and then scroll to the bottom.)

 

Posted in City Hall | 4 Comments

The Osher Life-Long Learning Institute

 

I’ve been taking courses and attending lectures for seniors offered by Cal State East Bay’s OLLI (Osher Life-Long Learning Institute) for several years.  It’s been a mind expanding experience and great fun.  OLLI offers lectures (free to members), courses (usually four weeks in length and reasonably priced), and a variety of field trips.

History, science, and literature are my own favorite topics, but the range of subjects offered is broad and the skills of the presenters impressive.  OLLI offers this rich trove at seven sites.  The two closest to Emeryville are the Lake Park Retirement Residence in Oakland and the Mastick Senior Center in Alameda.  The Baywood Retirement Residence in Castro Valley, the Danville Town Meeting Hall, the Reutlinger Community for Jewish Living, and Rossmoor in Walnut Creek aren’t all that far away.  The events at Cal State East Bay’s Concord Campus are a bit of a stretch for us but still inviting given the varied mix of offerings there.  If you would like to know more about OLLI, call 925-602-6776 or e-mail Kathleen Bryant, the Program Coordinator at kathleen.bryant@csueastbay.edu.  OLLI is also on line at www.scholarolli.com.  Give OLLI a try: no homework, no tests, no papers to write but intellectual challenges and the chance to meet interesting people! 

(Bill Reuter lives at Watergate in Emeryville and is Emeritus Professor of History, California State University East Bay.)

To comment on this story, hit the headline to go to story page, scroll to the bottom.

Posted in Arts/Culture, Education | 2 Comments

Berkeley, Emeryville pull out stops for lab campus

by Doug Oakley

Contra Costa Times

August 9, 2011
Berkeley and Emeryville officials wooed representatives from Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory on Monday, in hopes the institution will choose their cities to build a second campus for 800 scientists.

The meeting in Emeryville was the last of six held over the past three weeks that included Oakland, Richmond and Albany as possible sites for a new lab facility.

At each meeting, cities tried to show why their sites are the best. When the process is over and the second campus is finished in 2016, 800 scientists will go to work in 500,000 square feet of labs and offices, a size that could grow to 2 million square feet over time.

Landing the lab in any of the six proposed sites would be a boon for jobs and spending. Monday night’s proposal by Wareham Development was actually three in one: One alternative in Berkeley would house the lab on an 18-acre site just north of Ashby Avenue and Seventh Street; a second option would be located in Emeryville at Emery Station near the Amtrak Station; and a third would use both sites.

On hand to hear the proposals were lab Director Paul Alivisatos and Chief Operating Officer Jim Krupnick.

The site in Emeryville would use existing buildings — the lab’s Joint Bioenergy Institute is already there.

The site in Berkeley already houses the lab’s Joint Center for Artificial Photosynthesis and the lab’s life sciences division.

While Berkeley officials, including the city manager, the economic development manager and City Councilman Darryl Moore promoted Berkeley during the meeting, it was Emeryville officials who pulled out all the stops.

Speaking in favor of the Emeryville proposal were the city manager, deputy superintendent of schools, the fire chief, the deputy fire marshal, the police chief, the head of the chamber of commerce, the director of community services, the director for the Emeryville center for the arts and a group of school children who spoke about the educational possibilities of the lab partnering with Emeryville schools.

Emeryville police Chief Ken James promised quick responses to lab employees who find themselves in need of the law.

Mayor Nora Davis said Emeryville is the kind of place that embraces development.

“We have a track record of building things and getting it done,” Davis said. “If (the lab) wants to build a beautiful, sustainable campus in a city that is willing to start tomorrow, they will have chosen the right place.”

Emeryville fire Chief Kevin Johnston said the city is small enough to get problems solved with one phone call.

“You can actually call someone here, a city councilman or the fire chief, and get things done,” Johnston said. “And rest assured, with all the scientific labs that are already here, we have the expertise to deal with complicated buildings in an emergency.”

Krupnick said that while the lab will pick a preferred site for its second campus in November, that could change as it goes through the environmental impact review process that could take more than a year.

Doug Oakley covers Berkeley. Contact him at doakley@bayareanewsgroup

510-843-1408. Follow him at Twitter.com/douglasoakley.

To comment, click on headline to go to story page. Scroll to bottom.


Posted in Business/Economy, City Hall | 4 Comments

Richard Misrach: A focus on the after-story

Reprinted from

Richard Misrach: A focus on the after-story

August 1, 2011 1:00 pm by Tracey Taylor

Richard Misrach in his Emeryville studio where he has worked since 1976. Photo: Tracey Taylor 

Richard Misrach is nothing if not patient.

When, in 1997, the renowned photographer moved into a home in the Berkeley hills and decided to capture his new view of the Golden Gate Bridge, he didn’t just take a few dozen shots and leave it at that.

Rather, over the course of three years, he shot hundreds and hundreds of photographs. The result was Golden Gate [Aperture, 2005], 85 beautiful meditations on the iconic bridge seen through the seasons from a single vantage point on his front porch.

Similarly, when Hurricane Katrina swept through the Gulf Coast in August 2005, Misrach took his time before making the journey to New Orleans to document it. He waited until October, after the turmoil and drama had abated, to capture images of a post-storm calm that were no less dramatic.

But the most striking evidence of Misrach’s self-discipline must surely be his decision to wait 20 years before revealing the fruits of one of his major photographic projects. It is only now that the photographer is unveiling – in some cases printing for the first time — the photographs he took in the aftermath of the 1991 Oakland-Berkeley Firestorm.

His images will be shown at two exhibitions opening in October — at the Berkeley Art Museum and the Oakland Museum of California – scheduled to coincide with the 20th anniversary of the devastating fire.

The Oakland-Berkeley hills in the aftermath of the 1991 Firestorm. Photo: copyright Richard Misrach 

“I didn’t want to release the photographs straight away,” Misrach says, speaking in his studio, a cavernous space in an artists’ cooperative in Emeryville where he has worked since 1976.

“The meaning of photographs changes over time,” he says, explaining that he aims for his work to be the opposite of reportage or journalism. “Photographs can be really exploitative and I don’t want to be part of a media circus. History shifts the meaning.”

Misrach concedes it’s a gamble to wait for so long before unearthing work from storage. Out of the some 40 images in the upcoming exhibitions, and the book that will accompany them, only five have been exhibited before, in 2005.

“It’s interesting: I don’t know what I’ll see. And I’ve forgotten the logistics – was it three days after the fire when I took the photos, or four?

“But it feels right,” he continues. “The photographs are more poignant now.”

One of the images that will be on show at two local exhibitions this Fall. Photo: copyright Richard Misrach 

Misrach speaks in the same vein about the images he created of the eerily empty streets of New Orleans two months after the hurricane had careened though.

“I am attached to Louisiana and didn’t want to be part of a spectacle,” he says.

Granted a press pass by The New York Times Magazine, Misrach took a small 4MP Canon Powershot digital camera and shot most of the photographs almost on the hoof, a far cry from his trademark approach of using an 8 x 10 camera to produce painstakingly composed photographs that emerge as large-scale prints.

“I took 2,000 photos on the fly – sometimes from the car. It was the after-story, and it was post-apocalyptic,” he says. A number of images taken with a bigger camera have yet to be released.

The photographs, published in Destroy this Memory [Aperture, 2010], show the messages that officials and homeowners spray-painted onto houses, cars and scraps of board after the storm — whether to record the extent of the devastation or in reaction to it. The scrawls — warnings, pleas, even jokes — show a very human response to ruined lives.

This photograph, of a melted tricycle, will be presented in Misrach’s signature large-scale format. Photo: copyright Richard Misrach 

“I am here, I have a gun,” reads one; “Help! Help!” another; “Looters shot – survivors shot again,” is written in capital letters on a piece of plywood propped up against a tree; “RIP Thomas Burke, aka Tab,” is marked in blue chalk on a boarded-up garage.

“They are like primitive text messages,” Misrach says. “People’s graffiti showed both anger and humor and together they built a narrative.”

Misrach gifted full sets of the New Orleans prints to five museums and donated royalties from the book to the Make it Right Foundation.

He has also donated two full collections of the Berkeley-Oakland firestorm images to the Oakland and Berkeley museums that are exhibiting them this fall.

Misrach’s Berkeley roots go deep. He cut his teeth working with photographer Roger Minick at the ASUC Studio, a student arts facility at UC Berkeley from where he graduated in 1971.

“The first time I saw photographs as art in the studio I knew that’s want I wanted to do,” he says. “Roger held my hand. He was 22 and I was 19 but he seemed ‘so old’ to me. I looked up to him like a father figure.”

Misrach recalls how he started by working as a lab assistant at the studio – “a glorified janitor” he clarifies — mopping floors and cleaning up chemicals so he could use the facilities for free once the lab was empty at night.

“I would work from 11 p.m. through the morning,” he says. “They were lean times, I was house sitting and living in a van.”

Misrach captured the devastation caused by the Firestorm. Photo: copyright Richard Misrach 

Misrach’s first book “Telegraph 3am” [Cornucopia Press], black-and-white shots of street people taken on Telegraph Avenue, was published in 1974.

He went on to produce a highly regarded body of work — shooting in deserts at night, on the parched Bonneville salt flats, and in Mississippi’s Cancer Alley – his lens always focused on man’s relationship with nature, and bringing a socio-political edge to all his images

Misrach is considered one of this century’s most acclaimed photographers and is work is represented in more than 50 major museum collections around the world.

These days, the huge prints propped up around his studio and stacked flat in layers, like so many outsize millefeuilles, bear testament to the fact that he is experimenting. He says he has not used film for the past three years, and is working with digitally scanned negatives. “I’m moving from representational to experimental. I like the kind of work that always stretches me.”

The politics and culture of Berkeley, where he lives with his wife, the writer Myriam Weisang Misrach, have affected him profoundly, he says. Some of his earliest photographs were taken while he was being tear-gassed at anti-war riots on the Cal campus in 1969.

“Being in Berkeley was critical. My interest in aesthetics and politics merged and have been fighting each other ever since,” he laughs.

“If it weren’t for Berkeley I would be doing pretty landscapes.”

“1991: Oakland-Berkeley Fire Aftermath, Photographs by Richard Misrach” is at the Oakland Museum of California, October 15, 2011 through February 12, 2012, and at the Berkeley Art Museum, as well as a companion exhibition, “Richard Misrach: Photographs from the Collection”, from October 12, 2011 through February 5, 2012. An accompanying exhibition at OMCA will allow visitors to share their memories of the Firestorm.

The complete set of Telegraph 3 a.m is on view at Pier 24 in San Francisco. Many of the images from “Destroy This Memory” are currently on view at SF MOMA in its “Face of Our Time” exhibition.

(To comment on this story, click on headline to go to story page, then scroll to bottom).

 

Posted in Arts/Culture | Leave a comment